Author's note: I don't know what the law is in Alabama for third-degree murder, so this is my best guess, anyone who is better versed on this is more than welcome to correct me.
-----------------------------
Chapter 43: Mercy and Judgment
Montgomery, Alabama; Federal Court Building; February 10, 1964, 9:00 A.M. EDT:
It was a crowded, and closely guarded courtroom that Billy Robert McKay was led into that cold February morning. Outside the building Montgomery police, National Guard troops, and Army troops from the 101st Airborne were guarding the courthouse and other government buildings against rioters. The situation n Montgomery was still volatile and there were still reports of violence throughout the city, but the presence of the police, the Guard, and the Army had quickly turned the tide. Hopefully peace in the city might be restored soon.
Along with the inevitable number of reporters were members of Grace Baptist Church, including Miss Minnie May. The elderly woman had gotten up early to visit the jail where Billy Robert was being held but when she was arrived she was told that no one was allowed to see him until after sentencing. This morning the elderly lady had prepared some hot cinnamon rolls for Billy Robert and the officers. One of them promised Miss May that he would make sure Billy Robert got at least two of them.
That gratified Miss Minnie May. Her gift from the Lord she believed was being a good cook. And to her cooking was like praying. She offered prayer over everything she baked. The idea of Billy Robert going into his sentencing hearing on an empty stomach was simply not right, not right at all. Later, Detective Peterson had come up to her and told her Billy Robert had two of her delicious rolls with his coffee and asked the Detective to thank her profusely.
At 9 a.m. Billy Robert was brought into the courtroom handcuffed and shackled. At the sight of the young man being led in with his hands and feet shackled Miss Minnie May exclaimed, “Oh now why do you want to be leading him around like that? Take those things off him, he ain’t going to run away!” The exclamation drew a smile from the guards and from Billy Robert. Similar expressions came from some of the other members of Grace Baptist Church. After a moment’s consultation with the officer in charge, the officer leading Billy Robert in removed the handcuffs and leg shackles.
A few minutes later the judge entered, and all rose as he took his place at his bench. After gaveling the court to order he looked at Billy Robert and spoke.
“William Robert McKay, you have pleaded guilty to being an accessory to the bombing at Grace Baptist Church that claimed the lives of eleven people. Are you prepared to hear the sentence against you?” In a calm quiet voice Billy Robert replied, “Yes, your Honor.”
The judge paused. Billy Robert had pleaded guilty to being a party to the bombing. Under Alabama law that made him guilty of First-Degree Murder, punishable by life imprisonment or the death penalty. But, after Billy Robert had entered his plea, the judge had received a petition signed by all of the members of Grace Baptist who had survived the bombing and even the families of a few of those who had died asking him to show leniency and mercy to the young man. Among the signatories was the now nation-wide known “pie lady of Montgomery”, Minnie May. In addition, a letter asking for leniency had arrived from a gentleman with the initials MLK.
After taking a moment to consider all this the judge said, “William Robert McKay, it is the decision of this court that you will be sentenced for this crime but not on First Degree murder, rather you will be sentenced on eleven counts of Third-Degree murder all of which will be served concurrently. You are hereby sentenced to 20 years in the state penitentiary with time off to be considered for good behavior. This court stands adjourned! A bang of the gavel and the proceedings were done.
Several members of Grace Baptist Church looked satisfied and happy and with Miss Minnie May leading the way headed down to where Billy Robert was being led out of the courtroom. Miss Minnie May completely heedless of the guard came right up to Billy Robert and put her arm around his shoulder (no mean feat given Billy Robert was taller than her). Then she exclaimed, “The good Lord will be with you child, and don’t you worry. I’ll be visiting you each week with one of my pies. You just behave yourself in prison and you’ll be out in no time. I believe that. You were and are in my prayers every night!”
Other members of Grace Baptist gathered around Billy Robert and echoed the words of Miss Minnie May. Billy Robert teared up and wept saying simply, “I’m so sorry.” One of the members whose wife had died in the explosion put his hand on the man’s arm. “That’s all we and the Lord needed to hear son. You’re in his hands, remember that.”
Billy Robert nodded and was still in tears as the guard led him out. No one seemed to notice the guard was also trying to hold back some tears.