Punic Empire

Dorozhand

Banned
There are two POD's ITTL.
1) Hannibal manages to convince the Carthaginian council that his war is worth bending the state towards, and they decide to use the fleet to support him by blockading Roman ports and providing him with reinforcements and siege equipment.

2) Fabius dies before he can make his case about irregular warfare. The Romans try to raise one more army to defeat Hannibal, and it is annihilated like its predecessors.

After this, Hannibal besieges Rome and takes the city using the siege weapons and reinforcements provided from home. He goes on a killing spree and massacres or enslaves most of Rome's inhabitants, making good on his vow to destroy it. Capua replaces Rome as the principle Italian city, and the capital of the governate of Italy, which he puts in the charge of his brother, Hasdrubal. The rest of the peninsula would be subdued by the end of the decade, but unrest would pose a major problem.

Hannibal, after observing the situation in Italy, came to the conclusion that, in order to make the conquest stable, Carthage would have to grant the peoples ruled by the state the status of citizens equal to the Poeni. This greatly angered the council at home, but Hannibal's popularity was such that they relented and approved the action. It would be implemented and would work well in pacifying the Italian populace. Seeing the success of this reform, Hannibal then decided to work the concepts of the sacred band, and the new citizenship (as well as the intense personal loyalty that his mercenaries developed for him in Italy) to create the framework for a professional Punic army. He would use his new army, raised from Numidians, Iberians, Poeni, Capuans, Samnites, and various other ethnic groups under Carthaginian control, to launch two major campaigns. One to link Punic territory in Italy with Iberia, and one to conquer Dalmatia and Macedon.

The first campaign utilized the divide and conquer strategies learned during the conquest of Iberia, as well as the promise of citizenship, to subdue Gaul up to the Loire river. Hasdrubal would also lead a force from Italy that would conquer Massilia. Carthage would ally with the Aedui, allowing them the hegemonize much of the rest of gaul and act as a buffer state. The conquest was for the purpose of permanently linking Italy with Iberia, creating a defensible border, and realigning the politics of the Gallic tribes into a more favourable configuration.

After this, Hannibal would look to the east. Illyrian pirates were proving a hazard for Carthaginian trade from the Adriatic, so Dalmatia was subdued with help from the northern Iazyges (who moved further south ITTL and settled along the Danube). Carthage gave protection and some tribute to the Iazyges in exchange for their loyalty.

Feeling threatened by Carthaginian expansion, Macedon (who by this time has subdued all of mainland Greece) attacks Hannibal in Dalmatia, hoping to defeat him in battle and induce civil war in Carthage. His new professional army, bolstered by the Iazyges, annihilates the obsolete Macedonian phalanxes in battle after battle. Hannibal wisely took control of Greece, not by annexing, but by throwing off the Macedonian yoke and "freeing" the city-states to be tributary clients in reality completely at his mercy. The Dacians in the north would become enemies of Carthage, but Carthage would ally with the Bosphorans, who would distract them and act as a buffer along with the Iazyges. During both the Gallic campaign and this one, Hannibal was accompanied by his only son, Hamilcar II. He would teach him all the lessons that he learned, and would groom him to be a successor strong enough to brave the civil war that he knew would come after his death.

When Hannibal the Great finally dies in 165 BC, the council of Carthage, now free of his cult of personality, attempt to bring down the Barcas and roll back his reforms. Hamilcar II, who was mentored heavily by his father and accompanied him on campaigns, and the professional and loyal army defeat the mercenaries hastily hired by the council in the African mainland. Hamilcar II is popular among the Greeks, who either support him or revolt against Carthage entirely. Hamilcar, remembering what his father taught him (both about divide and conquer strategy, and the avoidance of unneccessary antagonizing actions), gives amnesty to, and recruits into the army, all rebels who turn themselves in, and uses the powerful sacred band to annihilate the primitive hoplites of the remaining Greek rebels. The cities in Africa that rebelled against him are not so fortunate. Their populations are enslaved and replaced by Poeni settlers (who, beginning under Hannibal, have been encouraged to settle throughout the state). During this time, the Numidians, divided by factions who rebelled and remained loyal, were absorbed under the direct administration of Carthage.

After the civil war, Hamilcar declares the council dissolved, and has himself crowned King of the Carthaginians.

Meanwhile, due to the lack of Roman influence in the mediterranean, and of a defeated Hannibal at his court, Antiochus III enthusiastically continues his advance into Egypt after the Battle of Panium. He decides to lead the army himself. Drunk with the dream of the Nile, his force becomes overstretched and he is encircled, defeated and captured by another Ptolemaic army raised completely from native elements. This, however, backfires spectacularly when the native egyptians of this army revolt against the now helpless Ptolemies after killing Antiochus and the captured Seleucids, and begin a new native dynasty.

During the chaos after the death of Antiochus, a Persian rebel army managed to bring down the Seleucids, establishing the Gotarzid Dynasty (named after the rebel leader Gotarzes), which made its capital the city of Nishapur. However, the Parthians would invade Persia later on and capture the indefensible Nishapur and much of the north and east. However, a member of the Gotarzid royal house would escape the capture of Nishapur and regroup the army in the south, defeating and checking the Parthians there. When further attacks on the Southern Gotarzids proved fruitless, the Parthians would expand north and eastwards toward lake Balkhash and around the Aral Sea, growing rich off the trade with China. At first the Northern Gotarzids fought against the Carthaginians, who would conquer Gotarzid territory in Mesopotamia and Arabia during this time, but when the Parthians invaded they allied with Carthage. Carthage would also ally with Armenia against Parthia, which would fight a proxy war with the Parthian client Media Atropatene.
The Southern Gotarzids would rebuild the city of Persepolis and make it their capital, and would usher in an era of great cultural, demographic, and technological development in Persia.

During the collapse of the Seleucids, Carthage under King Hamilcar II and his successors would slowly move eastwards, using the feared Sacred Band infantry and cavalry to subdue the cities and states in Anatolia and the Levant, while consolidating power in the western mediterranean. For a century, they would face no serious rivals, and the Barcid Dynasty would be blessed with a series of capable Kings.
During a civil war between the supporters of the king and an usurper in the first century BCE, the Germans poured through the Alps into Italy, and Carthage was dealt a heavy blow. They sacked cities and greatly reduced the wealth of north Italy, and established small petty kingdoms. Carthage would, however, under the great general-king Gisco II, beat them back across the mountains after a series of bloody campaigns known as the German Wars, and establish thereafter a permanent presence north of the Alps, building a series of forts in the passes.
Carthage would, after the German Wars, resume its eastward expansion. They would subdue the Garamantes, learning many of their secrets of irrigation (the water hadn't dried up yet), and would use this knowledge to establish a deeper presence along the north African coast, squeezing more agricultural bounty out of Mauretania and Tripolitania. Carthaginian colonists would establish settlements even beyond the Atlas mountains. Building upon Carthage's already rich naval tradition, navigators would reach the Canary Islands, and establish settlements as far west as OTL Tarfaya. The conquest of the Garamantes, extensive settlement in Libya, and the general agricultural explosion that ocurred at the time would allow King Hannibal III to lead a successful invasion of the decaying Kingdom of Egypt around the time of OTL's birth of Jesus. Hannibal IV would declare himself Pharaoh after the completion of the conquest. Expansion into Mesopotamia and south towards Qatar along the Persian Gulf, and friendly relations with the Southern Gotarzids, would allow Carthaginian ships to reach India easily. Carthage's powerful navy would dominate the northern Indian Ocean. This explosion of wealth would lead to a golden age of splendour and civilization.

Using the massive wealth of the empire, King Hannibal V built a new capital city in the region of Carthage's ancestral homeland. Named "Great City" in Punic, it would eventually gain a population of around one million, a figure no other city in the world would reach until much later in history. Carthage remained capital of the western half of the Empire, and administered the territories from Spain to Illyria, but the eastern capital would be the residence of the King, and would administer the much wealthier areas of the east. This would cause problems with civil wars later on, but in the short term, it made managing the realm much easier.
 
 
The Punic Empire at its height around 75 CE
 
Orange - Punic Empire
Light Orange - Punic Clients (Aedui, Iagyges, Armenia)

Deep Red - Nervii
Green - Redoni
Cyan - Caletes
Grey - Senones
Teal - Remi
Light Blue - Boii

Purple - Dacian Kingdom
Brown - Kingdom of the Bosphorans

Magenta - Arsacid Dynasty of Persia (Parthians)
Light Magenta - Media Atropatene (Arsacid Client)
Blue - Southern Gotarzid Dynasty of Persia


Carthage Empire.png

Carthage Empire.png
 
Last edited:
So, what you've done is essentially created a Carthaginian Roman Empire without acknowledging the inherent differences in Carthaginian and Roman state structure.

The hand-waved conquest of Gaul is, well, unrealistic as well. The territory you had them conquer is the realm of some of Gauls most powerful tribes including the Arverni, Bituriges, Allobroges, Volcae, Santones, and Pictones. Not to mention more than half of Hannibal's army was Gallic, so why would they not mutiny when they learned they'd be destroying their own homelands?

The Iazyges were steppe warriors who specialized in horse-archery. I don't think they'd fair very well in the mountainous regions of Illyria.

Also, that's not where the Bosphoran Kingdom was located. It was in the Crimea.

How on Earth is Antiochus III overstretched by invading Egypt, but Carthage isn't at this point? And that being the main point of why the hell is Carthage in Mesopotamia.

Look, I'm all for rule of cool. I really am! But you've got to do your research.
 
Yeah, I agree with Errnge. This also goes against the basic fundamental principles of the Carthaginian state-they were interested in a giant land empire-they were interested in being a maritime power that controlled the seas and the trade routes.
 
Awesome Sauce

I think you underestimated the Macedonian phalanx and Greek hoplites a bit - they were very good at what they did, even if they could only do one thing. Hannibal would probably run all over a one dimensional weapon like though. Things went perhaps a bit too easy for the Carthaginians. Rome's ascendancy in the period wasn't a string of victory after victory; they lost a good deal, but always sent another army to avenge their loss. And you only needed to lose to the Romans once to be assimilated. Additionally, empires put together by one man tend to fall apart rather quickly, though you have solved that problem by giving the Carthaginians a pretty sturdy second ruler. That said, it was very well put together.

So, what you've done is essentially created a Carthaginian Roman Empire without acknowledging the inherent differences in Carthaginian and Roman state structure.

It doesn't look like a Carthaginian Empire to me so much as a Barca empire. Hamilcar I, Hannibal, et al were carving out a personal empire in Iberia at the time that the Carthaginian state just went along with. This looks like an extension on that; Hannibal's crafty enough to adopt citizenship to mollify a conquered people.

The hand-waved conquest of Gaul is, well, unrealistic as well. The territory you had them conquer is the realm of some of Gauls most powerful tribes including the Arverni, Bituriges, Allobroges, Volcae, Santones, and Pictones. Not to mention more than half of Hannibal's army was Gallic, so why would they not mutiny when they learned they'd be destroying their own homelands?

Ceaser managed to conquer Gaul by his lonesome in ten years. Hannibal is at least Caeser's equal as a general, given enough time he could conquer at least that part of Gaul. His Gallic mercenaries could maybe be convinced to go along with it if they targeted tribes they were already opposed to. Then again, I really have no idea :p.

The Iazyges were steppe warriors who specialized in horse-archery. I don't think they'd fair very well in the mountainous regions of Illyria.

Also, that's not where the Bosphoran Kingdom was located. It was in the Crimea.

Both true.

How on Earth is Antiochus III overstretched by invading Egypt, but Carthage isn't at this point? And that being the main point of why the hell is Carthage in Mesopotamia.

It seemed like Antiochus suffered more of a tactical overstretch than a strategic one, though one can only imagine the strain placed on the Carthaginian supply lines. They did have quite a bit of luck in this timeline to get to where they are. Mesopotomia is going to cause Carthage some problems; it looks like they've only conquered up to the mountains there (I forget their name :eek:) and will suffer for it.
 

katchen

Banned
It looks like the way the Arcsids have expanded to the north, they will be running into problems with the Yuezi (Kushans). I'll bet on the Kushans coming out on top. Bigger headaches for Carthage. From Baal to Buddha.
 
Awesome Sauce

I think you underestimated the Macedonian phalanx and Greek hoplites a bit - they were very good at what they did, even if they could only do one thing. Hannibal would probably run all over a one dimensional weapon like though.

Even Hannibal could not be everywhere at the same time. To gain those lands at the east they would have to defeat the power bases of strong kingdoms-empires, and i don't see how you can do that in a single generation (not being the times of Dario, where they were unified). Now, obtaining key ports and the coastal isles is a lot easier to do and to maintain, being a maritime power.

I share the criticism on the conquest of Gaul, and extend it to Hispania. Hispania was enormous and not unified, you couldn't just defeat a single army and win and call it a day. You have to go slowly winning tribe by tribe... the way Carthage had been doing it. For Rome, the conquest of Hispania began before Gallia, and ended after Gallia.

Talking about Gallia, i can see them using the Seine to attack the Gauls in the rearguard. Were the Carthage ships river-worthy?

A thing i miss is coastal factories in all the areas they traded with, including Britain and Ireland. Becoming a powerful empire, i don't doubt they would want to create their own trading posts and factories in there, maybe even further into the Northern sea.
 
From my reading, I have the following critiques:

1) Hannibal, even if he were able to decisively defeat Rome, is going to face a lot of hostility from the leading Punic families in Carthage. His support was primarily in Spain, and there are going to be a lot of Cathaginians who are going to look at this semi-foreign general with suspicion (maybe he becomes an alternate-Caesar?)

2) As others have said, Carthage, at least at the time of Hannibal, is not in a position to conquer such a large Empire. Their history speaks against it, as does their population base.

So, let me propose the following scenerio: Hannibal wins, and wins big. He is able to decisively defeat Rome, and the Senate sues for peace. In the treaty which follows, Sicily, Sardinia and Corsica are annexed into Carhage proper, while the Greeks of Southern Italy are given their independance, albeit as loyal allies of Carthage. The Celts of Northern Italy are also given their indepenence, but its harder to secure and they may fall back to Rome over the next several decades.

Meanwhile, Hannibal's power becomes feared by the leading families of Carthage who have the General murdered. A civil war errupts and, eventually, a member of Hannibal's house is able to gain power and creates a monarchy.

You now have a centralized Carthagian state which is the strongest power, but not the dominant power, in the Medeteranian. Rome has been chastised, but is far from spent, and the threat of a new war looms large over everyone.

NOW, if you really want to see a strong Cathagian state beat Rome and supplant its place as THE Empire, might i suggest looking back a bit further to before the first Punic War. At the time, there was a struggle for Sicily which Carthage lost, largely because Rome supported the Greeks. If you are able to pull a Cathagian victory at this point (and Hannibal's grandfather, I believe, was the main general), you would have a Carthage which is able to strike at Rome from several different sides, and might be able to forment enough rebellion so that a *First Punic War ends with a decisive Cathagian victory.
 
Top