A Capetian saga (1065-1223)

Philip I (1040 – 1109)
PoD: The Hundred Years War begins with Alfred the Great, who after crushing the Vikings, claimed the French crown and invaded France. However, ITTL, the war is going on for more than a century and the western part of France is ruled by the Anglosaxons.

Philip I (23 May 1040 – 1 July 1109), called the Brave, was King of the Franks from 1065 to 1109.

Life

Early Years


Philip was born 23 May 1040 at Champagne-et-Fontaine, the son of Henry I and his wife Anne of Kiev. Unusual for the time in Western Europe, his name was of Greek origin, being bestowed upon him by his mother.

The year of Philip's birth is not recorded in the medieval documentation. According to one of the authors of the Anonymous Chronicle of Troyes, who met the monarch and was present at his death, he died at age 62 after reigning 44 years. This indicates that he was born in the second half of 1047 or in the first half of 1048. However, Ettiene of Lyon wrote that Philip was 69 when he died, but that would place his birth around 1040.

All the children of King Henry I, according to the Anonymous Chronicle , were educated in the liberal arts, and Phillip and his brother Hugh were also trained in arms, the "art of running horses in the French usage", and hunting. The cleric Fulk was in charge of Philip's early education. Once king, Philip appointed him Bishop of Orleans and referred to him as magistro nostro, viro nobile et Deum timenti ("our master, a noble man who fears God"). Philip Alfonso probably spent long periods with of Geoffrey II, Count of Gâtinais, where, with Fulk, the son of Geoffrey, he learned the art of war and what was expected of a knight.

Ascension to the Throne and Anglosaxon invasions (1086–1109)

After his coronation in January 1066, Philip had to confront the expansionist desires of King Harold Godwinson of England. However, the untimely death of the English king (December 24, 1072) gave way to a civil war (1072-1074) between his brothers Tostig, Earl of Northumbria (c. 1026 – 25 September 1073), Gyrth, Earl of East Anglia (c. 1032 – 1 July 1101) and Leofwine Earl of Kent (c. 1035 – 13 February 1074). Phillip took advantage of this situation and, determined to end the English dominion over half of France, struck deep into the lands held by the invaders. In 1074 he conquered the strategic fortress of Poitiers. This opened the way to the conquest of most of the Duchies of Gascony and Aquitaine by 1085.

By 1086, King Gyrth crossed the Channel and landed in Normandy with a great army. After gathering forces with the local lords at Caen, they marched toward Caen, which was then under French siege. There, on 23 October 1086, they faced the troops of Philip I. The battle ended with the defeat of the French king, who withdrew to Paris to defend the city, but Gyrth did not take advantage of the victory since he had to rush back to England because of the death of his elder son. The defeat marked the end of the French offensive as the military initiative was taken by the Anglosaxons and Philip I had to remain on the defensive. Nevertheless, he was able to retain Paris, the main target of the Anglosaxon attacks.

In 1088 Gyrth crossed the Channel for the second time, but was defeated at the siege of Blois and some feudal lords in England used the opportunity to rebel to force the king to accept their demands. Gyrth would not return, then, to France until 1090, after crushing and deposing the most conspicuous leaders of the revolt. Phillip used this time to conquer the Vexin. In June 1090, Gyrth launched his third attack, deposed the duke of Normandy and put into line the French Anglosaxon lords; then he completely crushed Phillip I and recovered most of Aquitaine. When Gascony was lost in 1094, the French king fell into despair, only partially healed by the successful defence of Orleans in June of that year, when Thibaut, Seigneur de Montmorency, responsible for defending the city, defeated the Anglosaxon army that had advanced against him in the Battle of Villemaury on 21 October.

In 1097, there was a fourth Anglosaxon invasion. Philip received the news when he was on his way to Flanders to seize the county as Robert II of Flanders was away on pilgrimage to the Holy Land. Once again, Gyrth's objective was Orleans, and he defeated the French forces at the Battle of Bonneval on 15 August, thus confirming the decline of the reign of Phillip I that had begun in 1086 with the defeat at Caen. By 1099, Gyrth had conquered a large number of the castles that defended Orleans and the surrounding areas and, in the following year, he tried unsuccessfully to seize the city.

In 1102 Philip I sent troops to help Orleans, but the campaign ended without a clear winner. The same year, he undertook the refortification of the area to protect the city. while trying to prepare for an eventual loss of Orleans. In 1104, 1105, and 1106, the king made several incursions into Maine and Touraine, reaching Le Mans in 1106. In 1108, King Edmund of England, son and heir of the late Gyrth, retaliated and attacked French territories, but this time the chosen city was not Orleans but Bourges. The armies clashed in the Battle of Bourges on 29 May 1108 and the French troops suffered another defeat, which opened a period of crisis in France that was to last for the next thirty years.

Death and Burial

Philip died in the castle of Melun and was buried at the monastery of Saint-Benoît-sur-Loire – and not in St Denis among his forefathers, thus fulfilling the wishes of the monarch. He was succeeded by his son, Louis VI. The mortal remains of the king were deposited in a stone sepulcher, which was placed at the feet of the church of the Royal Monastery, until the reign of Philip IV, who deemed it unseemly that his ancestor was buried at the foot of the temple and ordered the tomb to be moved inside and placed in the church's transept.
 
Last edited:
PoD: The Hundred Years War begins with Alfred the Great, who after crushing the Vikings, claimed the French crown and invaded France. However, ITTL, the war is going on for more than a century and the western part of France is ruled by the Anglosaxons.
Shouldn't this be ASB?
 
Really? I'm a bit surprised, I must admit.

It's not ASB really, but what I think the issue is - you start over a century and a half after the initial POD with England already in control of half of France, but don't really explain how we get there (save for the initial statement that it somehow comes about by Alfred the Great crushing the Norse more dramatically than in OTL). Leaving aside that a POD that far back is likely to enough to butterfly away the Godwinsons, let alone their control over England, you need to show us how Alfred manages to unite England after his victory, holds the new Kingdom together (in OTL it fractured after his death only to be pulled back together) and how his descendants go on to end up with over half of France in under their thumb.

All of this is ... unlikely, but certainly not impossible to pull off.

I understand that sometimes we want to jump to the good stuff with a timeline - and there can be something to be said not spelling everything out to the reader from the start and throwing them into the deep end of the pool. But in those cases, you still need to spend some time setting the scene and exploring the setting enough so that it feels more likely. Does that make sense?

I love any timelines relating to the Anglo-Saxon period; and one which basically theorizes an earlier Hundred Years War is certainly unique and bears some looking at. But I think you'd be better served by setting the scene more and showing us how we get to where we are at the start.
 
It's not ASB really, but what I think the issue is - you start over a century and a half after the initial POD with England already in control of half of France, but don't really explain how we get there (save for the initial statement that it somehow comes about by Alfred the Great crushing the Norse more dramatically than in OTL). Leaving aside that a POD that far back is likely to enough to butterfly away the Godwinsons, let alone their control over England, you need to show us how Alfred manages to unite England after his victory, holds the new Kingdom together (in OTL it fractured after his death only to be pulled back together) and how his descendants go on to end up with over half of France in under their thumb.

All of this is ... unlikely, but certainly not impossible to pull off.

I understand that sometimes we want to jump to the good stuff with a timeline - and there can be something to be said not spelling everything out to the reader from the start and throwing them into the deep end of the pool. But in those cases, you still need to spend some time setting the scene and exploring the setting enough so that it feels more likely. Does that make sense?

I love any timelines relating to the Anglo-Saxon period; and one which basically theorizes an earlier Hundred Years War is certainly unique and bears some looking at. But I think you'd be better served by setting the scene more and showing us how we get to where we are at the start.
You're absolutely right. Even more, you have laid out for me the prequel of this TL. Alàs, it would have to wait a bit.

But it will be done.
 
Another POD for this would be for Judith of France to have issue with her first or second husband, butterflying the House of Flanders.
 
Louis VI (1109-1126)
Louis VI (c. 1080 – 8 March 1126), called the Bold, was King of the Franks from 1109 to 1126.

Life

The place and date of Louis's birth are unknown, but she was born likely in Paris around 1080, the son of Philip I and his first wife, Bertha of Holland. Abbot Suger of Saint Denis, who wrote a biography of Louis VI, tells us: "In his youth, growing courage matured his spirit with youthful vigour, making him bored with hunting and the boyish games with which others of his age used to enjoy themselves and forget the pursuit of arms."

On 3 August 1115 Louis married Adelaide of Maurienne, daughter of Humbert II of Savoy and niece of Pope Callixtus II. They had one son. Adelaide was one of the most politically active of all France's medieval queens, even if Louis soon resented this and their relation became quite troubled. In spite of this her name appears on 45 royal charters from the reign of Louis VI. During her time as queen (1115–1118), royal charters were dated with both her regnal year and that of the king until their their marriage was annulled. It was the beginning of a troubled age for Louis, who had to battle several rebellious lords (with his half-brother, Philip, the son of Bertrade de Montfort, and the lord of Montfort-l'Amaury. Amaury III de Montfort. as the main leaders of the plotters).

Meanwhile, in the summer of 1109, the Anglosaxons conquered
Chartres and Bretigny, but Louis defeated and killed Godwine, the younger son of king Edmund of England in the battle of Rouvray (1110). However, as soon as the Anglosaxon threat diminished, the troubles with the rebellious lord resumed, forcing Louis to keep a fundamentally itinerant court: it used to spend the winter in Paris, but the rest of the year he toured the kingdom, with the aim of making the royal authority present in the territory, of gathering information about what was happening in the kingdom and to exploit it, by demanding compliance to the Crown. However, Philip and Amaury had succeeded in bringing together a coalition of barons with grievances against Louis, but the King defeated them in March 1113. However, he additional effort meant he could not campaign against the Anglosaxons.

The troubles resumed in 1116, while the Anglosaxons constantly raided the
county of Tolouse from 1110 to 1120. However, but the Tolosans managed to defend themselves well as a whole, partly favored by the punishment suffered by the enemy in the North at the hands of the Louis VI, who at that time raided Normandy and conquered Rouen in 1118. By 1119, buoyed by several successes and the capture (through treachery) of Gisors, Louis felt ready for a final encounter to conquer Normandy In the fierce Battle of Bremule, in August 1119, Louis's troops were routed, and the King , his health failing, looked for peace and successfully appealed to Pope Calixtus II.

The last years of Louis's reign are little known due to the lack of clear documents. From his study it can be deduced that the troubles with the nobility did not cease until his death in the year 1126, which occurred in Béthisy-Saint-Pierre.

Louis VI was interred in the Basilica of St Denis in Paris. He was succeeded by his son, Philip II.
 
Philip II (1126-1157)
Philip II (1105 – 18 September 1157), called the Great, was King of the Franks from 1126 to 1157.

Following the death of Duke William X of Aquitaine, Louis VI moved quickly to have his son married to Eleanor of Aquitaine, who had inherited William's territory (most of them under Anglosaxon occupation), to add the large duchy of Aquitaine to his family's holdings in France. Even if the marriage was agreed in 1125 (when Eleanor was four years old), it would not take place until 1136. (when she was fourteen).

Philip II's accession was marked by no disturbances other than uprisings by the burgesses of Orléans and Poitiers, who wished to organise communes. He soon came into a dispute with Pope Innocent II, when the archbishopric of Bourges became vacant. The king supported the chancellor Cadurc as a candidate to fill the vacancy against the pope's nominee Pierre de la Chatres. The pope thus imposed an interdict upon the king.

Philip II then became involved in a war with Theobald II of Champagne by permitting Raoul I of Vermandois, the seneschal of France, to repudiate his wife, Theobald II's sister, and to marry Petronilla of Aquitaine, sister of the queen of France. As a result, Champagne decided to side with the pope in the dispute over Bourges, opening war that lasted two years (1142–46) and ended with the occupation of Champagne by the royal army. However, the interdict still hanged over his head and, in 1150, he accepted Pierre de la Chatre as archbishop of Bourges and shunned Raoul and Petronilla. Desiring to atone for his sins, he declared his intention of mounting a crusade on Christmas Day 1150 at Bourges.

In the meantime, he resumed the war against the Anglosaxons in 1338. He would conquer Normandy in 1139, the county of La Marche in 1142 and Limoges and Perigord in 1144, even if the latter was lost again in 1145. As the Anglosaxon king Edmund II sent huge reinforcements to the other side of the Channel, Philip feared a new enemy offensive. However, Edmund II spent the next years consolidating his position in France and reinforcing the fortresses there. In June 1150, after pacting a truce with Edmund II, in fulfillment of his vow to mount the Second Crusade, Philip II departed to the Holy Land along with Conrad III of Germany. The French crusaders soon arrived in the Kingdom of Hungary, where they were welcomed by the king Géza II of Hungary, who was already waiting with the German Emperor. This started the good relations between the kingdoms of France and Hungary, which remained cordial long after this time. Just beyond Laodicea at Honaz, the French army was ambushed by Turks. In the resulting battle of Mount Cadmus, the Crusader suffered heavy losses, but Philip II and his army finally reached the Holy Land in 1151. His queen Eleanor supported her uncle, Raymond of Poitiers, and prevailed upon Phillip to help Antioch against Aleppo. However, during this period, there were rumours of an affair between Raymond and Eleanor, which caused tensions in the marriage between Louis and Eleanor. Furthermore, Philip's interest lay in Jerusalem, and so he slipped out of Antioch in secret. He united there with Conrad III and King Baldwin III of Jerusalem. However, as Baldwin III and the Knights Templar had Damascus as their main target and not Edessa, Philip joined them only half-heartedly. When this ended in disaster and the project was abandoned, Philip, anxious to return to France and to keep an eye on the Anglosaxons, decided to leave the Holy Land and returned home in 1152.

The expedition to the Holy Land came at a great cost to the royal treasury and military, which had as a inmediate result the loss of Limoges in 1157 at the hands of the Anglosaxons. Philip attempted to recover the county, but his campaign proved to be a failure and the king died while he was returning to Paris. His son Henri succeeded him as Henri II and his second son Hughes became Duke of Normandy.
 
Henri II (1149-1188)
Henri II (1135 – 18 September 1188) was King of France from 1149 to 1188. His predecessors had been known as kings of the Franks, but from 1190 onward, Henri became the first French monarch to style himself "King of France" (Latin: rex Francie).

He was nicknamed Dieudonné (God-given) by his father because, through him, Aquitaine became part of the royal demesne (even though it had to be reconquered first). Philip was determined to make Henri co-ruler with him before he departed to the Holy Land, so Henri was crowned and anointed as king at Reims on 1 November 1149. He was married on 28 April 1151 to Agnes of Hainaut, the daughter of Count Baldwin IV of Hainaut. The chaos that created the minority of his brother in Normandy led him to enter the duchy with an army and proclaimed himself the regent of Hughes in 1151. With the return of his father from the Holy Land the following year, Henri took a step back in the administration of the kingdom, but he was with his father when Philip II attempted to recover Limoges and died soon after. In 1156 he would return with an army to Normandy to Normandy, where he would remain putting down the rebellious lords until 1158, when his brother was able to rule the duchy by himself.

This internal affairs and the sorry state prevented Henri II from resuming the war against the Anglosaxons until 1166. By then, drastic changes had taken place on the other side of the channel. After the unexpected death of King Edmund II in 1152 without a male heir, his daughter Gunhild became the Queen of England when she was just a little over one year old. To settle the question and end the war, Henri II of France, who had no sons, proposed to marry Gunhild to his brother Hughes, but the Anglosaxon nobility had rejected the proposition and she was betrothed on 11 August 1153 to Malcolm IV of Scotland. Their first son, David I of England, was born in 1173.

Henri, who had used the time to reinforce his army and the navy by rising the taxes upon the Jews and by forcing them to pay ransoms to avoid some of them being expelled from the royal demesne, was forced to turn his attention to Flanders in 1166, when a conflict arose between himself and Thierry, count of Flanders about the border of the county of Vermandois. Thierry reacted by taking some fortresses on the border and then invaded France, ravaging the whole district between the Somme and the Oise before penetrating as far as Dammartin, but there he was attacked by Henri II, who defeated and routed the invaders. The Flemish raids resumed in 1169, but, as his allies abandoned him, Thierry was forced to conclude a peace. In July 1168, the Treaty of Boves left the disputed territory partitioned, with Artois, and numerous other places passing to the king,

Thinking that Henri was in a weak position, Malcom IV of Scotland attacked France in 1173 and attempted to take Toulouse. However, Henri was warned about Malcom's intention and mustered an army, then rushed to defend the southern city. After some minor skirmishes, Malcom withdrew in front of the more numerous French army. Two years later, his wife Agnes died and Henri married Adèle of Champagne, the third child and first daughter of Theobald II, Count of Champagne and Matilda of Carinthia, who died in childbirth in 1180.

In his last years, Henri II became estranged with his elder son and heir, the future Louis VII, and for a time he pondered about making his second son,
Charles, count of Dreux, his heir. However, when he died in 1188, nothing had been done about this question.
 
Last edited:
Louis VII (1188 – 1230) (1st part)
Louis VII (21 August 1171 – 14 July 1230) was King of France from 1188 to 1230.

The royal demesne had increased under Philip I and Philip II but had slightly diminished under Henri II. Henri, however, had overtuned this tendency in 1185, when he adquired the County of Amiens. Louis VII purchased the County of Clermont-en-Beauvaisis in 1218, and following the death of Robert I, Count of Alençon in 1219, Philip obtained the city and county of Alençon. Louis's eldest son, Robert, inherited the County of Artois in 1190, when Queen Isabella of Hainault died.

When his father died in 1188, Louis, who was 16 years old, faced unexpected troubles to be crowned. First, his brother Charles, count of Dreux, wanted to eliminate him, In addition to this there was the desire of the Anglosaxon king and the German emperor to divide up France. However, everything was resolved in favor of Louis, as Charles did not get enough support for his cause. As if the foreign threats were not enough, the new monarch found that the kingdom was bankrupt due to the policies that his father had carried out during his reign. With this situation, the sixteen-year-old monarch convened the famous Estates General of 1188, in which the representatives of the three estates (clergy, nobility and commoners), which were called by the king for the first time to intervene in matters of state. As the inhabitants of the cities enjoyed a great economic prosperity and qw the collaboration with the nobility in this aspect was too complicated, the king called the representatives of the cities to attend the États généraux and thus managed, without involving the nobility, to generate more resources for the Kingdom, resources that were increasingly necessary due to the growing expense caused by the wars with the neighbors; in exchange the king promised to improve the administration of justice and eliminate the abuses of power by the nobility.

His relations with his cousin, Philip of Normandy, were less successful. Although in 1188 he managed to sign an agreement of mutual support with Philip, when the Anglo-Saxons went on the offensive in 1188, Phillip did not move to help his royal cousin. Worse still, Phillip courted Frederick Barbarossa for an alliance, However, this came to naught when Frederick died in 1190 in Asia Minor while leading an army to the Holy Land in 1189; nevertheless, he would start a war with Louis for control of some castles on the border between his dukedom and the rest of the kingdom. Meanwhile, David I of England had his own problems, as he was unable to overcome the communal revolt of Brest, which became a republic ruled by consuls in 1189. At this juncture, David managed to arrange a white peace with Louis that restored the status quo ante bellum So the news of the fall of Jerusalem to Saladin ended any European conflict until 1192.

Louis (and Philip) travelled to the Holy Land to participate in the Third Crusade of 1189–1192 with King David II of England (born in 1158; David I had died while preparing to go on cruade), and Holy Roman Emperor Frederick I Barbarossa, leaving Vézelay with his army on 4 July 1190. Once in the Holy Land, the relations between Louis and David went soon from bad to worse and, after Acre surrendered on 12 July, Louis was severely ill with dysentery, which reduced even more his zeal. On July 31, 1191, as the French army remained in Outremer under the command of Duke Hugh III of Burgundy. Louis made their way to Rome, where he attempted to justify himself to Pope Celestine III (to no avail) and from there returned to France. However,t he Third Crusade ordained territory was under the protection of the Church in any event so he could not attack David' lands. In 1192, after returning from the crusade, David allied himself with Phillip of Normandy against Louis VII, who, in 1195, managed to buy the sympathies of Phillip II of Normandy, son and successor of Phillip I, put an end to this conflict without altering the correlation of forces between the constituted powers in France.

In spite of this, Louis attacked Maine in 1196, thus restarting the war with England and thus prompting the Anglosaxons' reaction. David landed in Brittany with a powerful army and marched directly to Maine, meeting French forces near Le Mans (July 19, 1196). The battle ended in a resounding defeat for the French army. Philip II of Normandy was very close to the battlefield, but not close enough for his troops to intervene in the battle and do anything to defeat the Anglo-Saxons. However, once the defeat was complete, Philip met in Caen with his cousin, the French king, to demand that he fulfilled the agreement and returned the border castles to him. Louis refused, and the duke left the meeting in anger.

After Le Mans, the war slowly turned against Louis over the course of the next three years. In 1197 Phillip II of Normandy ended up switching sides and returning to his alliance with David II. This was the state of affairs when Philip launched his campaign of 1198 with an attack on Vexin that was pushed back and then compounded by the Flemish invasion of Artois. By the end of the year, David II regained almost all that had been lost in 1193. In such a desperate situation, Louis offered a truce so that discussions could begin towards a more permanent peace, with the offer that he would return all of the territories except for Gisors. The meeting took place in mid-January 1199, but even if the two kings could not reach agreement on the terms of a permanent truce, but they did agree to further mediation, which resulted in a five-year truce that held against all odds.

During that time, David II reinforced his alliance with Phillip of Normandy and won a key ally, Baldwin IX of Flanders, who was married with David's sister, Eleanor (he also married his sister Constance with the Holy Roman Emperor, Otto IV). However, Otto was of little use to David as by 1212 the German Emperor was engaged in power struggles against Pope Innocent II. It wa then when Louis decided to strike. In order to secure the cooperation of all his vassals in his plans for the invasion of Aquitaine, Louis denounced David as an enemy of the Church for his alliance with Otto, thereby justifying his attack as motivated solely by religious scruples. Phillip of Normandy, seeing the writting on the wall, rushed to change sides again. He summoned an assembly of French barons at Soissons, which was well attended.

The battle that determined the course of the whole Anglosaxon-French war took place near the town of Bergerac, Gascony (July 16, 1212). There, Louis achieved one of the most important battles of the conflict. For many years the battle of Bergerac has been considered as the beginning of the decline of the Anglosaxon presence in France, even if the military and strategic consequences were limited, and the conquest of Aquitaine would not begin until some three decades had passed. The death of David II in the battlefield left England in the hands of his elder son, James, who was five years old.

However, the war was far from being over.

(to be continued...)
 
Top