Update 0: POD and setting the scene
"This is a publication of the inquiry of Herodotos of Thurii, so that the affairs of men do not fade with time, and the righteous and ignominious deeds--some done by Hellenes, other by Barbarians--not go unsung, as well as the causes that lead to the subjugation of Hellas by the Mede."
--Herodotos, Histories I.1
"While the speech of Themistokles, I believe, was wise, it did not persuade Eurybiades, who--I supposed--placed greater weight on the Pelopponesian's desire to protect the cities that were still held by Hellenes, than to the desire of the Athenians, who had already lost theirs. And so Themistokles, who foresaw the danger the Hellenes so placed themselves in, advised the captains of the Athenians to depart for Siris, and to found there the colony the oracle had spoken of. For although he had been until that point the best and most courageous defender of the freedom of Hellas, he preferred the liberty of exile to the ignominy of defeat"
--Herodotos, Histories 8.63
"The precise fate of the Peloponnesus, after the dissolution of the combined fleet at Salamis, is uncertain at best. Herodotus reports that the Peloponnesian fleet, lead by Eurybiades, never gave battle, and the Persians on advice from Greek deserters instead sailed to the Argolis after a token encounter with the fleet of Aegina. The Argives, 'preferring the tyranny of Xerxes to that of the Spartans', gave earth and water, according to Herodotus, and the Persian army marching north from the Argolis trapped the Spartans and their allies in the Isthmus of Corinth, where they fought in vain until their death. However, there is no archaeological evidence for the fortifications the Peloponnesians are traditionally said to have made at their isthmus, nor of a battle having taken place there. Indeed, aside from the total devastation of Sparta itself, and some signs of a reduction of the walls of Corinth, none of the devastation Herodotus reports can be confirmed as occurring. It is far likelier that the Peloponnesians deserted contingent by contingent as the Persians threatened their homes, and that the cities gradually accepted subjugation. The exception to this, of course, is Sparta and Messenia. In any event, however, their ultimate fate is clear enough; while no Greek inscriptions have been found at Susa, the prevalence of Doric inscriptions in both Bactria "where Zeus is called Tengrios" and Syria Palaestina has confirmed the deportation of Greeks to these territories roughly as Herodotus outlines".
--from the conclusion of a twentieth century paper on the incongruities of Herodotus and the archaeological record
"Can we really say that the Persians were tyrants and the Greeks fighting for freedom? I mean, they already had established some democracies in Ionia, and they by and large left alone the Argive democracy (or so it seems from Herodotus). Besides, they were the ones who liberated the helots and established them in Messenia."
"I mean yeah, but at the same time they unambiguously enslaved and deported a whole lot of Greeks. Herodotus recounts that some were sent to Susa to be slaves of the king, and presumably they were made the 'handmaidens' (concubines?) of the royal household that he outlined in Book IV. Others, of course, were sent against their will to Judea or central Asia."
--comments on a discussion forum for a liberal arts course on Herodotus.
--Herodotos, Histories I.1
"While the speech of Themistokles, I believe, was wise, it did not persuade Eurybiades, who--I supposed--placed greater weight on the Pelopponesian's desire to protect the cities that were still held by Hellenes, than to the desire of the Athenians, who had already lost theirs. And so Themistokles, who foresaw the danger the Hellenes so placed themselves in, advised the captains of the Athenians to depart for Siris, and to found there the colony the oracle had spoken of. For although he had been until that point the best and most courageous defender of the freedom of Hellas, he preferred the liberty of exile to the ignominy of defeat"
--Herodotos, Histories 8.63
"The precise fate of the Peloponnesus, after the dissolution of the combined fleet at Salamis, is uncertain at best. Herodotus reports that the Peloponnesian fleet, lead by Eurybiades, never gave battle, and the Persians on advice from Greek deserters instead sailed to the Argolis after a token encounter with the fleet of Aegina. The Argives, 'preferring the tyranny of Xerxes to that of the Spartans', gave earth and water, according to Herodotus, and the Persian army marching north from the Argolis trapped the Spartans and their allies in the Isthmus of Corinth, where they fought in vain until their death. However, there is no archaeological evidence for the fortifications the Peloponnesians are traditionally said to have made at their isthmus, nor of a battle having taken place there. Indeed, aside from the total devastation of Sparta itself, and some signs of a reduction of the walls of Corinth, none of the devastation Herodotus reports can be confirmed as occurring. It is far likelier that the Peloponnesians deserted contingent by contingent as the Persians threatened their homes, and that the cities gradually accepted subjugation. The exception to this, of course, is Sparta and Messenia. In any event, however, their ultimate fate is clear enough; while no Greek inscriptions have been found at Susa, the prevalence of Doric inscriptions in both Bactria "where Zeus is called Tengrios" and Syria Palaestina has confirmed the deportation of Greeks to these territories roughly as Herodotus outlines".
--from the conclusion of a twentieth century paper on the incongruities of Herodotus and the archaeological record
"Can we really say that the Persians were tyrants and the Greeks fighting for freedom? I mean, they already had established some democracies in Ionia, and they by and large left alone the Argive democracy (or so it seems from Herodotus). Besides, they were the ones who liberated the helots and established them in Messenia."
"I mean yeah, but at the same time they unambiguously enslaved and deported a whole lot of Greeks. Herodotus recounts that some were sent to Susa to be slaves of the king, and presumably they were made the 'handmaidens' (concubines?) of the royal household that he outlined in Book IV. Others, of course, were sent against their will to Judea or central Asia."
--comments on a discussion forum for a liberal arts course on Herodotus.
Last edited: